Shop Insurance.

Questions? Call 1.888.611.7467
Available: Mon-Fri 8AM - 6PM CST



Insurance Shop    About Insurance Shop    Agency Staff

Secure Form

Insurance Shop: Staff Directory

Welcome to our staff directory.  Our hardworking agents and support staff are the key to our success at Insurance Shop  They ensure that every customer receives prompt, professional grade service regarding their insurance needs.


Our agency is divided into teams of specialists to ensure that your insurance quotes and polices work as smooth as possible.  Find contact information for our primary team leaders in various commercial departments below or contact us for general inquiries.


Corporate Office


The Insurance Shop

3809 S. Providence
Suite A
Columbia, MO 65203

Local: 573.445.5535
Toll Free: 888.611.7467
Fax: 888.583.3110


Department:  Producers / Agent Leaders

Tim Davis- Sales Manager
Email: tim @
Extension: 25

Justin Bartmess
Email: justin @
Extension: 12

Alex McFarland
Email: alex @
Extension: 19

Curt Sieve
Email: curt @
Extension: 27


Josh Frerking
Email: josh @
Extension: 22


Shannon Dye
Email: shannon @
Extension: 26


Walter Capell- Principal
Email: wal @
Extension: 11


Department:  Customer Service- CSR Leaders


Jessica Kramer
Email: jessica @
Extension: 23


Christina Lindsey
Email: christina @
Extension: 14


Kayla Lindsey
Email: kayla @
Extension: 17


Shavon Barnett
Email: shavon @
Extension: 10


Roxie Robinson
Email: roxie @
Extension: 33


Department:  Accounting- Programs


Penny Sherrick- Accounting Manager
Email: penny @
Extension: 32


John Meier - Accounting
Email: john @
Extension: 16


Barb Davis- Program Reporting
Email: barb @
Extension: 20


Kami Griffith- Direct Reporting
Email: kami @
Extension: 17


General inquiries and all other staff
Email: info @
Extension- General Mailbox: 17


Image: Shop insurance with our secure forms.   Secure and Fast

Company Name:

Your Name:

Phone Number:


How Can We Help:


Featured Services


Which Business Insurance is Right for You?

Hot Commercial Insurance Products and Services

Sometimes you're looking for business insurance, but you're not sure what kind of policy you need.  With hundreds of different insurance categories, finding the right policy can be a difficult job.  The Insurance Shop can help.

Take the first step. Find out what you need and what rates you qualify for.

100% Satisfaction Guarantee

At Insurance Shop we are committed to the highest standards in customer service.  We take care of customers.


Need help with the commercial insurance process?

Contact an Agent Online or call 1.888.611.SHOP


Insurance Shop  |  Contact  |  About  |  Insurance by State  |  Licenses  |  Education Center  |  Forms  |  Press  |  Privacy  |  Sitemap

Copyright 2001-2011 All rights reserved.