Get a Quote

Personal Insurance

We offer flexible payment plans to fit any budget needs.

We offer flexible payment plans to fit any budget needs.

We've helped over 60,000 customers buy more affordable insurance coverage.

We've helped over 60,000 customers buy more affordable insurance coverage.

We shop your coverage with up to 35 national carriers.

We shop your coverage with up to 35 national carriers.

We shop your personal insurance to save you time and money.

Personal Insurance

Walt Capell started The Insurance Shop as a one-man business in his mid-Missouri garage in 2005. Walt knew he wanted to open a full-service agency that focused on the customer. What he didn’t know, was his little insurance agency would turn into a thriving small business that helps thousands of people every year in every state. At The Insurance Shop, we know shopping for personal insurance can be overwhelming. We see it as our mission to both inform and equip customers with the knowledge and products they need to protect their assets—to feel safe.

People don’t usually think of their lives in terms of risk or exposures to lawsuits, which makes it difficult to choose insurance to cover them. Buying a sub-par insurance plan or choosing to “take your chances” can be costly mistakes. The average homeowners insurance claim is $10,000 and the average personal auto claim is close to $1,000—both more costly than a yearly premium for the average customer. At The Insurance Shop, our specialists take the time to assess your coverage needs and help you to make educated decisions regarding your personal insurance coverages.

The Insurance Shop is an independent agency, we do not have exclusive partnerships with any insurance carrier. If you were to shop with a captive agent, someone who only works with one insurance company, your coverages would be restricted to only what one carrier can offer, including their prices. We have partnerships with over 35 national carriers and even more locally throughout the United States. With so many carriers to shop from, our experts can optimize your coverage and get you very competitive rates.

Let us help you insure your home, auto, pets and more.

Learn more about homeowners or personal auto insurance, or find the coverage you are looking for below and start a quote!

Insurance Services

Our Special Products and Services Make Us Better

Whether you are looking for the best coverage or to save more money over your current policy, our fast and friendly service staff is always here to help. As we work with numerous carriers across the United States we can offer more products at the best competitive rates. We at The Insurance Shop don't stop there, we also have a highly trained and experienced customer service team who guide and support you both before and after you've obtained your coverage.

EV SSL Certificate